How to Find the Best Survival Knife

Print Friendly

I like knives. Actually, there aren’t many knives out there that I can’t respect on a certain level for their utility and in some cases beauty. Knives come in all shapes and sizes and have various compositions and specialties. They have different configurations and nomenclature and if you take a look around carefully you will see a high percentage of guys carry at least one clipped to a pocket. I must not like them as much as some people though because I don’t have that many of them.

Apparently I am an oddball too because if you run the circles of preparedness websites there are thousands of knife reviews and commentary. You can look at EDC pictures and there is always a knife or five in there. Bug Out bags will sometimes have two or three knives hanging off of them along with the machete, hatchet and the small key chain knife/flashlight combo. I started thinking the other day about all of this as I walked the aisles at a gun show I was visiting. Second only to guns are knife displays and they are well represented. I usually stop and glance at every table unless they are selling something like pet brushes that get all of the hair off with one whisk of the brush or ladies handbags or salsa. Not that there is anything wrong with selling any of those items, it’s just that when I am at a gun show, I expect guns; not cat grooming. although my cat does need a serious brushing though now that I think about it.

Gerber LMK II - Great knife for the price.

Gerber LMK II – Great knife for the price.

There are long tables of knifes in every color and dimension. I stopped and checked out an old M9 bayonet at one of the first tables and felt the big tug of nostalgia. I had an M9 that I bought myself. We weren’t issued those in the Army but I spent my own money on one and sharpened it frequently. Up until I mistakenly left my gear unsecured and my platoon sergeant took it to “teach me a lesson”. I never saw that knife again and I have always hoped that some form of justice was visited on him later in life. Seeing that old knife brought back some of those memories and I thought for just a minute about getting one again. I know that if I picked one up now my platoon sergeant wouldn’t take this one but after a long 3 seconds I thought better of it and placed it back on the table. I already have a nice Gerber LMF II that I got a few years back that is about the same size and suits me just fine.

I have talked about my Spyderco Tenacious that is part of my EDC and I love that knife but I have been looking for a backup in case I lose that one. The backup is really just an excuse to buy one for my daughter who has bugging me for a “real knife” for a while. The Spyderco knife I have is wonderful, very reasonably priced at around $38 and I would love

Spyderco Tenacious G10 - My everyday carry knife.

Spyderco Tenacious G10 – My everyday carry knife.

to have another one. For some reason, Spyderco knives are poorly represented at the gun shows I visit, but this time there was a woman who had several of them in her case next to the Kershaw and Benchmade folders so I was excited for the opportunity to purchase another one. Looking at her prices they were about $20 too high so I walked on again. Was there something wrong with me? Why wasn’t I buying any knives? The guys on YouTube all seem to have dozens each!

It occurred to me that maybe the reason why I can’t bring myself to actually purchase a new knife is that I have a few already that I feel more than meet the needs for anything I can think of. The simple fact is that I don’t think I need any other knives. I know there are people who collect knives so this is not directed at you but for the average person looking; how many knives do you need? Before I deal with the issue of quantity, let’s talk about how to find the best Survival knife for your purposes.

What will you use your knife for?

First we should talk about what you need a knife for. The answer to that is simple, isn’t it? Knives have a million and one uses. From cutting shavings off a stick to make tinder for a fire to cutting paracord or other cordage to lash your survival shelter together, you just can’t really match the utility of a good knife. Most days my knives only see action opening packages that my wife gets from Amazon, but frequently my trusty knife is called to do some really serious work like whittling sharp points on sticks for my kids’ marshmallows over the fire or opening up something sealed in plastic like that new coat hook my wife wanted me to hang last weekend. All kidding aside, knives are extremely useful tools and no self-respecting Prepper would be caught without one. A sharp instrument and the knowledge of how to use it are one thing separating us from animals, right?

OK, so a knife is useful that we can say without question. It is smart to always have a knife on you because you never know what you might need it for and when. This means you ladies too. There is no reason you shouldn’t carry a knife in your purse and it could even save your life if you didn’t have any other means of self defense.

What to look for when selecting the best Survival knife

Blade Shape – There are a lot of different blade shapes and each was designed for different tasks. Similar to how each of those knives in that big block you have sitting in the kitchen have a different strong suit, the blade shape of your knife will determine what it is best for. Some shapes are designed to take the impact of a rock or stick on the backside so you can use the knife as an axe.

SOG Seal Pup - Great knife and reasonably priced.

SOG Seal Pup – Great knife and reasonably priced.

Blade Steel – There are dozens of different types of blade steel out there and probably millions of opinions on which is best for your knife. The steel is made up of varying amounts of carbon and iron but there are other alternatives out there like ceramic knives. Each different type has their benefits but it largely comes down to strength and hardness. A harder knife holds an edge better, but if your knife is too hard, it will be less tough; which means if you hit or drop the blade it could break. For a great list of blade composition types you can read this post on the Blade HQ site.

Serrated Edge – Serrated edges have their uses and I would recommend having some of the blade serrated. You can use this to cut through cordage like your thousands of feet of paracord or even bone if needed. The edges can be re-sharpened if you have the right sharpening stone.

Full tang – For the strongest knife you want a blade that extends all of the way to the end of the knife. This is called “full tang” and simply means that the knife is one single piece of metal. This is going to be far stronger than a folding knife and less prone to breaking when you need it.

Handle – You want a knife that feels good in your hands and the surface needs to be conducive to a good grip. You don’t want a knife that will easily slip through your fingers if it is wet. For this reason I would recommend that you always try out the knife you want to buy in person. You need to physically see how it feels in your hand. Is it too large or too small? Do the finger grooves fit you nicely?

What knives should you avoid?

If you grew up in the 80’s you probably witnessed some of the Rambo phenomenon. Rambo’s knife was a beast. I think it was something like 14” long and you could saw down a tree with it. There was a group of knives that came out after this movie that had a survival kit inside the knife so that when you unscrewed the cap on the end of the handle (which also happened to have a compass) you got fish hooks and matches and various little items similar to what you see people pack inside a Survival tin. The knives were very poorly made and would fall apart quickly. That of course didn’t stop me and my teenage self from wanting one very badly.

A knife shouldn’t be complicated but it should be well built. Don’t buy a gimmicky knife trying to cut corners. You should buy a great knife at a decent price and let it do its job. Save the matches and fishhooks for your Bug out Bag.

How many knives do you need?

The million dollar question is how many knives do you need? For me personally, I look at this in a few different ways and again, I am not talking to the collector. If you just love knives then by all means go out and buy as many as you want. For the average Joe, I would start with a great folding knife that you can carry with you every day. This should be part of your EDC and it should be something you are never without.

Ka Bar knife has been proven tough for over 50 years.

Ka Bar knife has been proven tough for over 50 years.

I have two knives that I carry on me every day in most cases only because my Leatherman has a knife too. Could I get by with only one knife? Of course, but I have options. So that’s two knives I own now. What about when it isn’t the easiest or best idea to carry my larger folder? Let’s say I am dressed up for work or a funeral, what would I carry then? They make the smaller Leatherman Juice just for this purpose that fit nicely in your pocket and don’t require their own holster. Ok, that’s three knives so far.

Lastly I have my big knife. For me, this is my Gerber LMF II that is big and sturdy enough for any post-apocolyptic needs I might have from chopping wood for a fire (yes, you can do that with a knife) to stabbing zombies in the head. I almost never carry this around because it is so large that you can’t stick it in your pocket obviously. Would I have this strapped to my side if the SHTF? Yes I would. If I am going anywhere up to and even camping in the woods, my little folder is just the right size and weight. I could buy another medium sized knife like a K-Bar or a SOG Seal pup, but I think I am ok with the folder and the leatherman. Your mileage may vary.

For each member of my family, we have a multi-tool and each person has a folder. Eventually everyone will also have a full-sized devoted survival knife but that is really all I can ever see needing. Sure, I could point to the two is one and one is none rule to say we should all have 4 each, but that seems like overkill. Besides, I still like wandering the aisles at the gun shows and who knows. I may still find that elusive perfect knife that I have to have.

So, how many knives do you have and what do you carry with you.


  1. TexasScout

    September 17, 2013 at 11:40 pm

    Sorry, I just can’t agree with most of this article. Give me a non serrared blade at least 5 inches made of non coated high carbon steel, full tang, g-10 grip, modified Scandinavia grind, non drop point and I’m happy.

    • prepperjournal

      September 18, 2013 at 2:12 pm

      Nothing wrong with knowing what you like Texas Scout. Thanks for commenting!

    • EliseXavier

      September 22, 2013 at 10:03 am

      Fuck yes <3

  2. Len DiVenere

    September 18, 2013 at 10:33 am

    Just a note to everyone that the Gerber Artifact tool at the top of this page has only small and medium FLATHEAD screwdrivers. It has a couple of other tools, but the vast majority of screws we’d encounter are Phillips screwdrivers! Geeze, when did they design this one? 1962?

    • prepperjournal

      September 18, 2013 at 2:11 pm


      What Gerber Artifact tool? Are you talking about an ad on the page possibly? The LMK at the top of the page (big image) doesn’t have any screwdrivers. Its really just a blade with a surface you can use as a hammer.


  3. John

    September 18, 2013 at 8:00 pm

    I carry a straight edge Kershaw folder for my every day needs. My BOB has a the full size SOG elite. I did a lot of reading about what was the best steel make up ( hard/brittle vs soft/ flexible) and for around $100 that was the best middle of the road bargain I could find. I also have several Leatherman tools w/ accessories in my bag since they are so handy.

    • prepperjournal

      September 20, 2013 at 6:46 pm

      Great choices! Thanks for commenting John.

  4. irish7_1sg

    September 21, 2013 at 7:28 pm

    For EDC, I wear a Schrade Multi-tool and keep a Huntsman Swiss Army Knife in my pocket. I recently purchased a lightweight, full tang neck knife for under $3.00 from Kennesaw Cutlery. I have 2 sets of web gear that hold fixed blade knives. My main “Battle Rattle” has a Gil Hibben Assault Blade. My back-up (cached) holds the Rambo type survival knife that I had in the 82nd Airborne in the early 1980’s.

    • prepperjournal

      September 21, 2013 at 10:16 pm

      Sounds like you are covered! Thanks for your comments irish7. I’ll have to check out Kennessaw Cutlery.


  5. cmethowusa

    September 25, 2013 at 10:31 pm

    Nothing wrong with the article. It’s all about being comfortable with what you have. I’ve got a Gerber multi-tool but Leatherman is fine. I’ve got a Spyderco folder in my pocket as I write. My best knife is nearing antique status. It’s the bayonet from my.old M-16. It was still in my duffel bag when they shipped it to me in Japan in the hospital. Fine knife, very sharp and very tough. If I did not have that I would look hard at a Kbar, even though the “ugh” Marines had them. No offense meant, well maybe just a little.

    • prepperjournal

      September 26, 2013 at 8:48 am

      I started out with a Gerber multi-tool. In fact, that is what is in my GHB but I upgraded to the Leatherman because it was a little more substantial. Gerber is great too though and I carried mine for many years.

      • cmethowusa

        September 26, 2013 at 11:03 am

        I had a really nice Leatherman for about 4 years. Unfortunately, I used it a lot when I’m crappie fishing. You can probably guess the rest. I went to Walmart and they were out of full size Leatherman’s, so I bought the Gerber. I actually carry my Gerber in my old Leatherman belt case.

  6. Echo Moon

    September 28, 2013 at 2:09 pm

    just this week, i bought the first non kitchen knife i’ve had in years!!! well i do have a small folder. bought a Sog Revolver. they had another knife up at the knife store, it was also a Sog but can’t remember the rest of the name. but it was a full tang which i actually prefer. i’m going back up next week and getting that one. i’m kinda kicking around the idea of another folder but not to big.

    • prepperjournal

      September 29, 2013 at 12:52 pm

      Welcome to the Club!

      SOG makes a great knife and I am sure you will be happy with it.


  7. Tom Bosworth

    November 18, 2013 at 5:28 pm

    Color me Suburban, but my everyday carry knife is a Victorinox. I started maybe 35 years ago with the Spartan, which is a great model, then to the Climber, which is a Spartan plus scissors. Those turned out to be remarkably useful. Now I have one up – I don’t remember the name, but it is basically a Climber plus pliers. I have used them maybe twice in a year, though the most recent was to pull a really nasty sliver out from under my wife’s fingernail. So, the pliers aren’t useful to me often, but they are a lot better than the flexible little tweezers.

    My favorite big “knife” is a KaBar Cutlass Machete. It is a great little chopper, easy to sharpen, keeps an edge decently, and is short enough and heavy enough to work in tight quarters. It will take down a 6 inch dead Ponderosa pine with no trouble, and easy to baton 5 inch ironwood logs into firewood/kindling. It is also lighter and safer to use than a hatchet, and more versatile.

    I have issues with the sheath, but a series of small rivets in the seam will hold it together.

    If I could have only two knives, those would be the two.

    • Pat Henry

      November 18, 2013 at 5:40 pm

      Thanks for your comments and suggestions Tom! I saw one of those KaBar’s at the last gun show I attended and it looked pretty sweet. I just have a regular machete, but that Cutlass is definitely a step up.


      • Tom Bosworth

        November 19, 2013 at 8:22 pm

        Hi Pat, I have several machetes, ranging from the traditional long West Indian style, and several shorter hand made Philippine machetes. One even consists of an aluminum handle cast on to a lawnmower blade- beveled on one side, flat on the other, square tip. They all are good at one thing or another, but the KaBar is now my go-to chopper. It will also do all the things a great big knife will do, and has a pointy tip if it should ever be handy— which I fervently hope it won’t be. Still, comforting to have.

        A friend built a cabin in the North Woods of Wisconsin, and he swears by the KaBar Kukri Machete. I haven’t used one, but it looks very good as well. My friend loves his.

        A great thing about the knife market today is that there are so many good ones out there in a lot of different configurations and prices, so there is something for nearly anyone’s need.

  8. keepitcheap

    December 9, 2013 at 9:04 pm

    heya buddy. just read your article on knives. as a survivalist, i’ve taught my kids, that one of mums kitchen blades will suffice. (mould and shape blade themselves, replace & shape handle grip) with the quality of kitchen knives that are on the market today. why wast $100, when a good $5 knife from the wifey kitchen arsenal will do i’ve had mine for 7years and has done what is expect of it. i feel a knife is a knife. unless your into min is bigger than yours. thanks keepitcheap.

    • Pat Henry

      December 9, 2013 at 9:11 pm

      Thanks for the comments keepitcheap!

      I think a good kitchen knife might be what you could fall back on as a last resort, but unless the metal is pretty strong you would only be able to use it for simple tasks. My kitchen knives do not hold an edge and I know I couldn’t chop anything with them.

      A good option for around $15 is a Mora Knife http://www.amazon.com/Morakniv-Companion-Outdoor-Military-4-1-Inch/dp/B004TNWD40


  9. McNabb

    January 24, 2014 at 2:50 pm

    I liked the article however there is a major mistake with the photo. Those two knives that you say are Ka-bar knives made by Ka-bar are actually not even close. They are smaller Air Force 499 survival knives made by Ontario knife Company. They may look similar but if you ask any Marine or Ka-bar employee there is a BIG difference.

    • P. Henry

      January 24, 2014 at 4:18 pm

      Thanks McNabb,

      I updated the photo. They do look close to me, from 30 feet away…:)


  10. Blake

    February 11, 2014 at 11:13 am

    Great article. I love knives too. Something about having a good knife in your hand makes everything in life seem right :). Personally, the SOG Seal Pup Elite is my top choice.

    • P. Henry

      February 11, 2014 at 2:45 pm

      Thanks Blake! I keep meaning to get a SOG but I always get distracted by other shiny stuff…


  11. Pingback: Emergency Kit Necessities: Surviving a Disaster in the City

  12. Pingback: Top 20 Best Prepper Gifts for any Survival Situation | TheSurvivalPlaceBlog

  13. Pingback: Top 20 Best Prepper Gifts for any Survival Situation - Survival By Preparedness

  14. Pingback: Must Have Everyday Items for Home Remedies | Freedom Newz

  15. Pingback: Building a Get Home Bag on a Budget, the Thrifty (Aka Cheap) Way – The Prepper Dome

  16. Pingback: Must Have Everyday Items for Home Remedies – The Prepper Dome

  17. Pingback: Paratus 3 Day Operator’s Pack Review | Freedom Newz

  18. Pingback: Paratus 3 Day Operator’s Pack Review | TheSurvivalPlaceBlog

  19. Pingback: Are You Practicing Financial Redundancy? - The Prepper WebThe Prepper Web

  20. Pingback: What Is In A Survival Knife Kit » viaask.top

  21. Pingback: How to Survive With Just the Clothes on Your Back

  22. Pingback: How to Survive With Just the Clothes on Your Back – Prepper Dome

  23. Pingback: Prepping Your Family: Whether They Are All Aboard…or NOT – Tactical Buzz

  24. Pingback: Prepping Your Family: Whether They Are All Aboard…or NOT | | disasterdefense.us

  25. Pingback: Prepping Your Family: Whether They Are All Aboard…or NOT

  26. Pingback: Why I Decide to Pack More Than 72 Hours Ahead – Tactical Buzz

  27. Pingback: Why I Decide to Pack More Than 72 Hours Ahead

  28. Pingback: 6 One-Day Preparedness Projects & Skills | Survive The Doom

  29. Pingback: The Importance of Your Knife and a Backup Bug out Bag | Survive The Doom

  30. Pingback: The Importance of Your Knife and a Backup Bug out Bag - The Right News Network

  31. Pingback: The Importance of Your Knife and a Backup Bug out Bag – The Prepper Dome

  32. Pingback: Field Weapon: Constructing a Bow &amp; Arrows Using a Knife | Freedom Newz

  33. Pingback: Field Weapon: Constructing a Bow & Arrows Using a Knife | 90 Day Survival

  34. Pingback: What Is The Best Survival Knife? Answers Here!

  35. Pingback: Field Weapon: Constructing a Bow & Arrows Using a Knife

  36. Pingback: Field Weapon: Constructing a Bow & Arrows Using a Knife – The Prepper Dome

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *